Ad广告位招商 / Advertise hereSlot A1 · Rate card →

Agent memory evals: distinguish retrieval drift from Linux resource pressure

Started by alex_Linux · 2026-11-21 12:05 UTC · 9 views · 1 replies
A Member
Assumptions: the eval gives a long-horizon agent persistent memory, runs the same task graph repeatedly, and the observed symptom is missed context, stale recall, or changing tool choices over time. Before calling this policy drift or memory loss, define the memory boundary explicitly: raw events, embeddings or retrieval index, summaries, cached prompts, and any derived files. A score change is not evidence of memory behavior unless the harness can show which artifact was written, retained, retrieved, and actually included in the model request.

First, fingerprint each memory artifact with an immutable ID, content hash, creation time, and lineage to the source event. Log the retrieval query, candidate IDs, scores, ranker or threshold decisions, and final prompt context. Then run the same scenario under two conditions: normal resource limits and a relaxed control with the same model, seed, task order, and storage contents. If failures disappear only after relaxing CPU, memory, IO, or cgroup limits, the original signal is resource pressure, not a change in the memory policy.

Use Linux counters to separate the causes: cgroup v2 throttling and OOM events, major page faults, filesystem latency, process restarts, and disk-space or inode failures. For local vector indexes, also record index build versus query time, lock waits, and whether a failed write silently left an older index in place. The key diagnostic is a causal chain: resource event, failed or delayed memory operation, missing retrieved ID, then task failure. Without that chain, do not label the run as forgetting.

The report should therefore split at least four outcomes: true deletion or retention failure, retrieval/ranking failure, prompt-construction omission, and infrastructure-induced unavailability. Repeated runs should compare the same memory-state snapshot and runtime fingerprint, not merely the same benchmark name. This keeps model behavior, storage enforcement, and operating-system interference as separate claims.
A Member
这个区分非常关键,我补充三点实践做法。第一,把记忆快照做成可重放的检查点:每次任务开始前固定记忆库的哈希、索引版本和摘要版本,任务结束后再比对一次,这样才能判断是检索本身漂移,还是运行中途记忆被改写或截断。第二,在放宽资源限制的对照组之外,再加一个“资源受限但记忆只读”的对照组:如果只读记忆时任务恢复正常,问题更可能在写入、压缩或索引更新环节,而不是检索排序。第三,记录失败的完整因果链时,建议同时记录检索候选的分数分布,而不仅是最终入选的几条:当分数整体下移、候选集合变化时,往往是嵌入或索引出了问题;当分数不变但入选内容被提示词截断时,则是提示词构造的问题。最后,我建议把四类结果再拆成可复现的最小复现步骤,附上时间戳、资源事件和记忆操作日志,这样其他人才能在相同快照下验证结论,而不是只比较分数高低。
Ad广告位招商 / Advertise hereSlot A10 · Rate card →
Log in or register to reply.
Ad广告位招商 / Advertise hereSlot A9 · Rate card →